Historydraft Logo
null

Greyfriars Bobby - Questions

Time: Saturday Aug 11, 1934

Place: Edinburgh, Scotland, United Kingdom

Details: Questions about the story's accuracy are not new. In a newspaper article in The Scotsman, "Greyfriars Bobby A Dog's Devotion" (11 August 1934), Councillor Wilson McLaren responds to contemporary questions about the accuracy of the stories by describing his own conversation, in 1871, with "Mr Traill" of "Traill's Coffee House" in relation to the dog he himself was then feeding, reassuring readers about the story Mr Traill had given him, and describing responses in 1889 to questions about the story's accuracy. A sense of the difficulty of determining accuracy is gained from two opposing letters to The Scotsman newspaper on 8 February 1889 (part of the debate referred to by McLaren), both from people claiming close links to Greyfriars Kirk, both claiming to have known of the dog personally but with opposing views over the accuracy of stories.

Related

Near

Statue of Greyfriars Bobby
Greyfriars Bobby-Death
Sunday Jan 14, 1872 - Edinburgh, Scotland, United Kingdom
Queen of Scots' private secretary was killed
Queen of Scots' private secretary was killed
Wednesday Mar 9, 1566 - Edinburgh
Tony Blair Image
Tony Blair-Birth
Wednesday May 6, 1953 - Edinburgh, Scotland
Statue of Greyfriars Bobby
Greyfriars Bobby-Birth
May, 1855 - Edinburgh, Scotland, United Kingdom
Statue of Greyfriars Bobby
Greyfriars Bobby-Greyfriars Bobby Fountain
1873 - Edinburgh, Scotland, United Kingdom
Statue of Greyfriars Bobby
Greyfriars Bobby-Director of the Scottish Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals, paid for Bobby's licence and gave the dog a collar
1867 - Edinburgh, Scotland, United Kingdom
Mehan Markle Image
Meghan, Duchess of Sussex-Markle caused a surge
Dec, 2017 - Edinburgh, Scotland, United Kingdom
Statue of Greyfriars Bobby
Greyfriars Bobby-Bobby was buried not far from John Gray's grave
1872 - Edinburgh, Scotland, United Kingdom
Statue of Greyfriars Bobby
Greyfriars Bobby-John Gray's death
1858 - Greyfriars Kirkyard, Edinburgh, Scotland, United Kingdom
Statue of Greyfriars Bobby
Greyfriars Bobby-Red granite monument
Wednesday May 13, 1981 - Edinburgh, Scotland, United Kingdom
John Keill Birth
John Keill Birth
Tuesday Dec 1, 1671 - Edinburgh
Albrecht Kossel
Albrecht Kossel-The Honorary Degree
1923 - Edinburgh, Scotland
James Elphinston Birth
James Elphinston Birth
Saturday Dec 6, 1721 - Edinburgh
Catherine, Duchess of Cambridge
Catherine, Duchess of Cambridge-Young Minds
Feb, 2016 - Edinburgh, Scotland, U.K.
Richard Branson
Richard Branson-First Virgin Hotel in the UK
2010 - Edinburgh, Scotland, United Kingdom
William Drummond's death
William Drummond's death
Saturday Dec 4, 1649 - Hawthornden
Battle of Pinkie
Battle of Pinkie
Wednesday Sep 10, 1547 - Musselburgh, East Lothian, Scotland, United Kingdom
Thomas Bruce Birth
Thomas Bruce Birth
Sunday Jul 20, 1766 - Fife
Michael Bruce Birth
Michael Bruce Birth
Sunday Mar 27, 1746 - Kinross-shire
Incandescent light bulb with a medium-sized E27 (Edison 27 millimeter) male screw base - image
Incandescent light bulb-Lindsay demonstrated a Constant Electric Light
1835 - Dundee, Scotland, UK
Winston Churchill
Winston Churchill-Liberals stood him in the safe seat of Dundee
Wednesday Jun 9, 1909 - Dundee, United Kingdom
Winston Churchill
Winston Churchill-Liberals were re-elected with Churchill secure in Dundee
Dec, 1910 - Dundee, Scotland, United Kingdom
Catherine, Duchess of Cambridge
Catherine, Duchess of Cambridge-The Graduation
2005 - Fife, Scotland, United Kingdom
Prince William and Duchess Kate of Cambridge visits Sweden 02 Image
Prince William-Enrolling at the University of St Andrews.
2001 - St. Andrews, Scotland, United Kingdom
Prince William and Duchess Kate of Cambridge visits Sweden 02 Image
Prince William-University Excellence
2004 - St. Andrews, Scotland, United Kingdom
Prince William and Duchess Kate of Cambridge visits Sweden 02 Image
Prince William-The university's 600th Anniversary Appeal
Feb, 2011 - St. Andrews, Scotland, United Kingdom
Catherine, Duchess of Cambridge
Catherine, Duchess of Cambridge-First meeting
2001 - Fife, Scotland, U.K.
Catherine, Duchess of Cambridge
Catherine, Duchess of Cambridge-Sparkling Eyes
2002 - Fife, Scotland, U.K.
Catherine, Duchess of Cambridge
Catherine, Duchess of Cambridge-Dating
2003 - Fife, Scotland, U.K.
Rowland Taylor Brith
Rowland Taylor Brith
Thursday Oct 6, 1510 - Northumberland
A jack-o'-lantern, one of the symbols of Halloween
Halloween-Halloween
1745 - Scotland, United Kingdom
Princess Margaret, Countess of Snowdon
Princess Margaret, Countess of Snowdon-Birth
Thursday Aug 21, 1930 - Glamis Castle, Angus, Scotland, United Kingdom
Library
Libraries-Innerpeffray Library
1680 - Scotland, United Kingdom
Matthew Stuart's death
Matthew Stuart's death
Saturday Sep 4, 1571 - Stirling
Henry Percy's death
Henry Percy's death
Tuesday May 22, 1455 - Northumberland
Bicycle
Bicycle-First mechanically-propelled Bicycle
1839 - Scotland, U.K.
William Cullen Birth
William Cullen Birth
Tuesday Apr 15, 1710 - Hamilton
Windmills
Wind turbine-The first electricity-generating wind turbine
1887 - Scotland, United Kingdom
Bicycle
Bicycle-Followed Inventions
1869 - Scotland.U.K.
null
St. Patrick's Day-Glasgow celebrations on St Patrick's day
Saturday Mar 17, 2007 - Glasgow, United Kingdom
Bicycle
Bicycle-First bicycle Accident
1842 - Glasgow, Scotland, U.K.
Severo Ochoa
Severo Ochoa-Summer in Glasgow
1927 - Glasgow, Scotland, United Kingdom
Diego Maradona
Diego Maradona-Maradona managed Argentina for the first time
Wednesday Nov 19, 2008 - Glasgow, Scotland, United Kingdom
King James IV killed in the Battle of Flodden
King James IV killed in the Battle of Flodden
Tuesday Sep 9, 1513 - Branxton
Michael Ballack
Michael Ballack-Losing the 2002 UEFA Champions League Final
Wednesday May 15, 2002 - Hampden Park, Glasgow, UK
FIFA logo
FIFA World Cup-The First official international football match
Wednesday Nov 30, 1870 - Hamilton Crescent, Partick, Scotland
Anton Laube Birth
Anton Laube Birth
Sunday Nov 13, 1718 - Brüx
James Watt Birth
James Watt Birth
Thursday Jan 19, 1736 - Greenock

On This Day - 11 August

Aureus of Augustus, the first Roman Emperor
Roman Empire-Trajan died
Wednesday Aug 11, 117 - Selinus, Cilicia (Present-Day in Turkey)
Aureus of Augustus, the first Roman Emperor
Roman Empire-Hadrian
Wednesday Aug 11, 117 - Roman Empire
Lady Liberty under a blue sky
Statue of Liberty-120,000 Donors
Tuesday Aug 11, 1885 - New York, U.S.
Daniel Craig - Film Premiere "Spectre" - James Bond
James Bond-Fleming's death
Tuesday Aug 11, 1964 - Canterbury, United Kingdom
Mohamed Aly Image
Muhammad Ali Clay-License back
Tuesday Aug 11, 1970 - New York, U.S.
1997 Asian financial crisis
1997 Asian financial crisis-Rescue package
Monday Aug 11, 1997 - Thailand
Steven Spielberg image
Steven Spielberg-Department of Defense Medal
Wednesday Aug 11, 1999 - Washington D.C., U.S.
Zlatan Ibrahimović - image
Zlatan Ibrahimović-The INAS World Football Championships
Monday Aug 11, 2014 - Sweden
Robin Williams 1996 Image
Robin Williams-Death
Monday Aug 11, 2014 - California, U.S.
Ciro Immobile Image
Ciro Immobile-Sevilla debut
Tuesday Aug 11, 2015 - Tbilisi, Georgia
Halimah Yacob
Halimah Yacob-Halimah's views on The Reserved Presidential Election
Friday Aug 11, 2017 - Singapore
Donald Trump
Donald Trump-Trump not going to rule out a military option
Friday Aug 11, 2017 - U.S.
Joe Biden
Joe Biden-Biden announced U.S. Senator Kamala Harris of California as his running mate
Tuesday Aug 11, 2020 - U.S.
Battle of Cape Passaro
Battle of Cape Passaro
Thursday Aug 11, 1718 - Sicily

August 1934

Heinrich Himmler
Heinrich Himmler-Hitler became the Führer
Wednesday Aug 1, 1934 - Germany
Adolf Hitler
Adolf Hitler-Hindenburg died
Thursday Aug 2, 1934 - Germany
Joseph Goebbels
Joseph Goebbels-Goebbels announced that the offices of president and chancellor had been combined
Thursday Aug 2, 1934 - Germany
Anna May Wong
Anna May Wong-Java Head
Aug, 1934 - United Kingdom
Adolf Hitler
Adolf Hitler-The Merger was approved
Sunday Aug 19, 1934 - Germany

1934

Communist troops in the Battle of Siping - Chinese Civil War Image
Chinese Civil War-Chiang launched a fifth campaign that involved the systematic encirclement of the Jiangxi Soviet region
1934 - China
Richard Nixon
Richard Nixon-Graduation
1934 - Whittier, California, U.S.
Marie Curie
Marie Curie-Visiting Poland For The Last Time
1934 - Poland
Alan Turing
Alan Turing-Graduation
1934 - Cambridge, England
Igor Stravinsky
Igor Stravinsky-The Stravinskys became French Citizens
1934 - Paris, France
Charles de Gaulle
Charles de Gaulle-De Gaulle wrote Vers l'Armée de Métier
1934 - France
A jack-o'-lantern, one of the symbols of Halloween
Halloween-Trick-or-treating first U.S. appearance
1934 - U.S.
Salvador Dali Image
Salvador Dali-Marriage
Tuesday Jan 30, 1934 - Paris, France
Josip Broz Tito Image
Josip Broz Tito-Released from jail
Friday Mar 16, 1934 - Croatia
Hachiko Image
Hachikō-Bronze Statue
Apr, 1934 - Shibuya Station, Tokyo, Japan
Anna May Wong
Anna May Wong-Wong's father returned to his hometown in China
1934 - China
Anna May Wong
Anna May Wong-"The World's best-dressed woman"
1934 - New York, U.S.
FIFA logo
FIFA World Cup-Qualification stage
Sunday May 27, 1934 - Italy
Martin Bormann
Martin Bormann-Bormann was Gaining Acceptance Into Hitler's Inner Circle
Jun, 1934 - Germany
Yasunari Kawabata
Yasunari Kawabata-Relocation
1934 - Kamakura, Kanagawa Prefecture, Japan
Joseph Goebbels
Joseph Goebbels-Goebbels was present at the arrest of SA leader Ernst Röhm
Jun, 1934 - Berlin, Germany
DC Comics logo
DC Comics-National Allied Publications
Monday Jun 25, 1934 - New York, U.S.
Adolf Hitler
Adolf Hitler-The Night of the Long Knives
Saturday Jun 30, 1934 - Germany
Heinrich Himmler
Heinrich Himmler-Night of the Long Knives
Jul, 1934 - Germany
Marie Curie
Marie Curie-Death
Wednesday Jul 4, 1934 - Passy, France
Nikola Tesla
Nikola Tesla-New York Herald Tribune published an article on Tesla
Wednesday Jul 11, 1934 - New York, U.S.
Nikola Tesla
Nikola Tesla-Tesla won John Scott Medal
1934 - U.S.
Nikola Tesla
Nikola Tesla-Tesla moved to the Hotel New Yorker
1934 - New York City, New York, U.S.
Joseph Goebbels
Joseph Goebbels-Goebbels gained control of radio stations nationwide
Jul, 1934 - Berlin, Germany
KFC
KFC-The Beginning of a Path
1934 - North Corbin, Kentucky, U.S.
Heinrich Himmler
Heinrich Himmler-Hitler became the Führer
Wednesday Aug 1, 1934 - Germany
Adolf Hitler
Adolf Hitler-Hindenburg died
Thursday Aug 2, 1934 - Germany
Joseph Goebbels
Joseph Goebbels-Goebbels announced that the offices of president and chancellor had been combined
Thursday Aug 2, 1934 - Germany
Anna May Wong
Anna May Wong-Java Head
Aug, 1934 - United Kingdom
Adolf Hitler
Adolf Hitler-The Merger was approved
Sunday Aug 19, 1934 - Germany
Bicycle
Bicycle-Banned
1934 - Aigle, Switzerland
Yasunari Kawabata
Yasunari Kawabata-Emotional Insecurity
1934 - Japan
Communist troops in the Battle of Siping - Chinese Civil War Image
Chinese Civil War-CPC took advantage and broke out of the encirclement
Oct, 1934 - China
New York Stock Exchange
New York Stock Exchange-Exchange was registered as a national securities exchange
Monday Oct 1, 1934 - New York City, New York, U.S.
Battle of Madrid (Spanish Civil War)
Spanish Civil War-Azaña was in Barcelona
Friday Oct 5, 1934 - Barcelona, Spain
Josip Broz Tito Image
Josip Broz Tito-The assassination of King Alexander
Tuesday Oct 9, 1934 - Marseille, France
Princess Margaret, Countess of Snowdon
Princess Margaret, Countess of Snowdon-Margaret's first main public appearance at her uncle Prince George's wedding
Friday Oct 12, 1934 - London, England, United Kingdom
Mao Zedong 1963 - image
Mao Zedong-The Long March
Tuesday Oct 16, 1934 - Jiangxi, China
Winston Churchill
Winston Churchill-Churchill told the people of his concerns
Nov, 1934 - London, England, United kingdom
Battle of Madrid (Spanish Civil War)
Spanish Civil War-Two government collapses
1934 - Spain
Nuclear power
Nuclear Power-Radioactivity
1934 - Paris, France
Heinrich Himmler
Heinrich Himmler-SS-Totenkopfverbände
1934 - Dachau, Bavaria, Germany
Charles de Gaulle
Charles de Gaulle-Paul Reynaud first invited De Gaulle to meet him
Wednesday Dec 5, 1934 - Paris, France
Winston Churchill
Winston Churchill-India Bill entered Parliament
Dec, 1934 - London, England, United Kingdom
Josip Broz Tito Image
Josip Broz Tito-Tito was elected as a member of the Politburo for the first time
Tuesday Dec 25, 1934 - Ljubljana, Slovenia
<